Armchair Hockey Scout

Ask the book

2023-24 edition Ask a direct question about this edition of the book — who, how many, how common, which group more — and it is answered with a table computed on this page from the edition’s index: the season line, height and age, the on-ice percentiles, the grades and the traits read out of every report. Ask for a view on named players — what a comparison comes down to, what makes a man — and you get the book’s reading of their own pages, and only those. The model turns your question into a query and phrases the result, or reads the pages it is handed; it never originates a figure, and an answer carrying a figure that is on neither the table nor the pages is withheld. It does not forecast, and it says so when a question is outside what the book holds.

Tables are computed on this page from the 2023-24 edition’s index; readings rest on the players’ own pages; the model never counts. Twenty questions an hour.

Montreal Canadiens

Atlantic Division, Eastern Conference · 24 reports in the 2023-24 edition.

This is the 2023-24 edition — an archived read, written from that season alone. Read the 2026-27 club page →

The club

2022-23 · 82 games · 244 for, 214 against

How it played

Shot attempts share, five-on-five
45.5% 28th of 32
Expected goals share, five-on-five
44.0% 30th of 32
Power play expected goals per sixty
7.10 15th of 32
Penalty kill expected goals allowed per sixty
8.28 31st of 32

Where the record lies

Finishing goals scored above what the chances were worth
+15.0 5th of 32
Goaltending goals prevented beyond what the chances allowed were worth
-13.2 24th of 32

Montreal Canadiens scored 15.0 more goals than their chances were worth but got 13.2 fewer saves than the chances they faced warranted — the two pull against each other, and both regress.

Roster shape

Points-weighted, so these are the ages and origins of the production rather than of the sweaters.

Average age
24.9
weighted by points
From 33 and up
0.0%
of skater points
From under 26
64.0%
of skater points
Homegrown
33.3%
drafted by this club
Continuity
91.6%
of last season's five-on-five minutes

The read

the numbers, and the eye

Thirtieth in the league in chance share and fifth in finishing — the exact opposite of Carolina, and it produced 68 points.

Who this names 4 of 24 on the roster · 18% of their five-on-five minutes details

Both columns above are searched, and a name counts on the same terms the page links it: in full always, by surname only when one man in the edition wears it. Nothing here says who ought to be named — only who was, so the weighting can be seen rather than guessed at.

Not named here: Jake Allen, Josh Anderson, Joel Armia, Justin Barron, Kirby Dach, Christian Dvorak, Jake Evans, Brendan Gallagher, Jordan Harris, Rafael Harvey-Pinard, Johnathan Kovacevic, Mike Matheson, Sean Monahan, Samuel Montembeault, Michael Pezzetta, David Savard, Juraj Slafkovský, Nick Suzuki, Arber Xhekaj, Jesse Ylonen.

What the Quant Says

31-45-6, 68 points, 28th in the league and last in the Atlantic.

232 goals for, 26th. 307 against, 29th. Twenty-eighth at creating chances at even strength, 30th at suppressing them, 30th in chance share, 30th on the power play and 29th on the penalty kill.

At five-on-five: 162 goals scored against 147.0 expected, and 200 conceded against 186.8. The finishing was 5th in the league at plus-15.0 and the goaltending 24th at minus-13.2.

That first figure is the whole page. Montreal was thirtieth in the league in chance share and fifth in finishing — the exact inversion of Carolina, which was first in chance share and thirty-first in finishing. Carolina finished second overall with 113 points. Montreal finished twenty-eighth with 68. The lesson this book keeps drawing is that finishing does not survive a season and chance share does, and these two clubs are the demonstration printed side by side.

Nick Suzuki's ice scored 18 goals more than the chances deserved. Cole Caufield scored 26 goals in 46 games. Kaiden Guhle registered a 24.2 mph top speed at 21.

Alex Newhook and Gustav Lindstrom arrive. Jonathan Drouin, Mike Hoffman, Evgenii Dadonov, Chris Tierney, Alex Belzile and Chris Wideman do not.

Six of this roster's regulars are 23 or younger and three of them are first-round picks who have played less than a full season each. This club is not trying to be good yet, and the page does not read as though it were.

What the Scout Says

The most extreme finishing season in the league, on the club with the second-worst chance share in it.

Montreal took 44.0 per cent of the expected goals at five-on-five, 30th in the league, and scored 15.0 goals more at five-on-five than its chances were worth, 5th. Nick Suzuki's ice alone accounted for 18 of them.

The young players are real and the structure around them is not. Everything on this page that looks good is a percentage, and the two things that will still be true next season are Suzuki's minutes and Caufield's shot.

The roster

Evidence 0 Full 22 Light 2 No record

No measured season behind two of them: Jake Allen and Samuel Montembeault. Their pages carry an older stat line and a judgment, and nothing from 2022-23.

34

Jake Allen

Evidence behind this report: No record. No five-on-five record — Allen did not play a measured season. Everything on the page is an older line and a judgment.

G · Montreal Canadiens

An .8914 behind the club that conceded the third-most goals in the league, and his fourth straight season of decline.

17

Josh Anderson

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

RW · Montreal Canadiens

Two hundred and twenty-six pounds, and the heaviest man in the league's top ten for bursts of speed.

40

Joel Armia

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

RW · Montreal Canadiens

Six foot three, a first-round pick, and his ice scored twelve goals in forty-three games.

20

Justin Barron

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

A first-round pick who came the other way in the Artturi Lehkonen trade, and a 9th-percentile chance share.

13

Cole Caufield

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

RW · Montreal Canadiens

Twenty-six goals in forty-six games, two penalty minutes, and twenty-four of the goals from inside forty feet.

77

Kirby Dach

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

Third overall in 2019, ninety-four shots from inside forty feet, and the seventh percentile for registered shot speed.

22

Christian Dvorak

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

A 77.0 mph shot — the third-softest registered in the league — from the second-hardest deployment in it.

71

Jake Evans

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

Two goals on fifty-five shots, and seventeen assists.

7

Brendan Gallagher

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing, only 459 five-on-five minutes. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

RW · Montreal Canadiens

Two thirty-goal seasons behind him, and four straight years of missing at least a quarter of the schedule.

21

Kaiden Guhle

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

A 24.2 mph top speed at twenty-one, at 20:31 a night, and a minus-19.

43

Jordan Harris

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Eighteen and a half minutes a night at twenty-two, and thirty-seven shots from beyond forty feet for nothing.

48

Rafael Harvey-Pinard

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing, only 459 five-on-five minutes. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

LW · Montreal Canadiens

Seventy-five per cent of his shots came from inside twenty feet — the most concentrated shot chart in this book.

8

Johnathan Kovacevic

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Winnipeg gave him four games and put him on waivers; Montreal gave him seventy-seven and the best chance share on the blue line.

27

Gustav Lindstrom

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Eighteen shots on goal in thirty-six games, and two goals in a 128-game career.

8

Mike Matheson

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Twenty-four and a half minutes a night, thirty-four points in forty-eight games, and the seventh-most ground covered in the league.

23

Sean Monahan

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing, only 296 five-on-five minutes. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

Five straight twenty-goal seasons in Calgary, and twenty-five games in the last one.

35

Samuel Montembeault

Evidence behind this report: No record. No five-on-five record — Montembeault did not play a measured season. Everything on the page is an older line and a judgment.

G · Montreal Canadiens

Three seasons under .8940 and then a .9011, behind the club that conceded the third-most goals in the league.

15

Alex Newhook

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

The 96th percentile in bursts of speed, and thirty points from thirteen minutes a night.

61

Michael Pezzetta

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

LW · Montreal Canadiens

Nine minutes a night, seventy-seven penalty minutes, and the lowest distance reading in these five chapters.

58

David Savard

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Twenty-two minutes a night at 21.0 miles an hour, from the hardest deployment on the club.

20

Juraj Slafkovský

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing, only 433 five-on-five minutes. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

LW · Montreal Canadiens

First overall in 2022, thirty-nine games at eighteen, and the lowest chance share on the club.

14

Nick Suzuki

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

C · Montreal Canadiens

Sixty-six points and a 13th-percentile chance share, and his ice scored eighteen goals more than the chances deserved.

72

Arber Xhekaj

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

D · Montreal Canadiens

Undrafted, six foot four and 240 pounds, and four of his five goals came from beyond forty feet.

56

Jesse Ylonen

Evidence behind this report: Light. Thinner than most: part of the record is missing, only 457 five-on-five minutes. The page is honest about what it has, but it is a smaller sample than the book's norm.

RW · Montreal Canadiens

Zero penalty minutes in thirty-seven games, and six goals on twenty-nine close-range shots.

How they were used

2022-23 · 82 games

Measured from shift charts at five-on-five, not projected. Units are built from the strongest partnership outward and ordered by how much they were used; the percentage is the share of the first player’s five-on-five ice time spent alongside each linemate. A low number means the club never settled on a combination. Players who have gone are marked — either to another club, or off an NHL roster altogether, which covers retirement and an unsigned summer alike.

Forwards

First line

Second line

L Mike Hoffman now SJS 12%
L Jonathan Drouin now COL 23%

Third line

Fourth line

C Chris Tierney now NJD 26%
R Alex Belzile off the roster 35%

Defence

First pair

Second pair

Third pair

D Chris Wideman off the roster 41%

Goaltending

By games played

G Jake Allen 42 GP
G Cayden Primeau 3 GP